Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Welcome to YUI Lover: The 1st YUI Forum & Fansite. We hope you enjoy your visit.

You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.

CLICK HERE to join our community!

If you're already a member please log in to your account to start sharing YUI LOVE!

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
YUI MV being Copy; Huh... Damn director
Topic Started: Aug 4 2007, 01:59:12 AM (2,795 Views)
Dnee Chan
Member Avatar
Can't Buy Me Love

Hmm... Just read One of Indonesian Tabloid and there is some News That
Desert Chang(Chang Xuan) New MV Xi Huan Is said copied from YUI MV My Generation. Netter from internet show many same thing between That New MV with YUI MV. Apparently it is hard to said its just a Lucky to be same.

Get acusation like that several times after that Desert and his Manager Request Sony BMG to immediately stop to show That MV (Xi Huan) and they Not even Publication and Circulate That MV again.

And The Director of That MV apologize and he feel regret for that accident. According to that director before he made that MV he saw YUI MV and some MV for consederation . Of course when making MV, scene that he have been seen show up in his mind and not intentionally Copied

Sorry for my bad english (just try to translate :) )


EDIT:
The Desert New MV : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AuaDBUGNrWE
Posted Image
 
yui knight
Member Avatar
CoZ of YUI, I'm Always Laugh Away...

yeah... i ready seen too...

oh too bad :(

darn2 :bash
Posted Image
My Friendster | Yui-indo Forum | My Blog
 
JustAnotherYUILover
Member Avatar
Troglodyte with a change of heart.

Oh wow! I thought people were exaggerating when I took a glimpse of the summary provided by Dnee. Then I went to watch the MV. Wow. . . The beginning is almost exactly like the beginning of My Generation. The parts where some people(s) are flipped upside down also adds to this. . . Also the thing about the guitar pick. What a shame. :huhuhu
 
natchi
Member Avatar
- I CHANGE ME -

haih.... too bad, but luckily the director did apologized and the MV has been stopped from circulation..... but one thing, it means YUI's gettin popular lol! even oversea directors would take notice of her XD
Posted Image
http://www.youtube.com/user/natchi86mk2
http://twitter.com/natchi86
http://www.last.fm/user/natchi1986
 
Helixius
Member Avatar
Always YUI-ing

The beginning and ending are really copied!! haha.
The rest of the MV seems alright to me...
Posted Image
 
dUStyEX99
Member Avatar


i not sure but it seem that more than one of YUI's mv sences was used... I wonder he really never watch YUI's mv before...
 
j.k
Member Avatar
Resurrected

Seems like YUI's gettin more and more famous lately. but who does she think she is?! She's not as cute as YUI,the song's not as nice as My Generation,her voice is nothing compared to YUI's, and most importantly, she's a copy cat!!!! She's blacklisted!!!!!! :evil
Posted Image
 
mono
Member Avatar
We are YUIing!!

j.k
Aug 4 2007, 05:38 AM
Seems like YUI's gettin more and more famous lately. but who does she think she is?! She's not as cute as YUI,the song's not as nice as My Generation,her voice is nothing compared to YUI's, and most importantly, she's a copy cat!!!! She's blacklisted!!!!!! :evil

You can't say something like that blaming the singer
It is the director who filmed the MV and did the copying thing,not that singer
And it is the singer who asked Sony BMG to stop showing the MV and give apology
Though I dunno the singer, from what she did in this incident, she gives me a good impression
Posted ImagePosted ImageYUI-net
Posted Image
 
sonic87
I LOVE YUI!!!

Yea... I agree with momo... Its the director at fault... Not the singer... Its only unfortunate that such things happen... But since the director has apologised and the PV is no longer going to be circulated, lets just forget about it... ;)

PS : This song and My Generation are 2 different songs genre... You can't compare them just like that... Besides, every singer have their own fans... Its not very nice to say that...
 
*simply_kawaii*
Member Avatar
Call me *sky* for short..^^

it's ok since the director of that pv apologized for his mistake.. :lol:
sig made by me XD
Posted Image

 
j.k
Member Avatar
Resurrected

right...sorry bout what i said about her earlier :swt ...it's just that i dun like it when somebody tries to copy YUI. well,since everyone says it's ok,guess there's no point to dwell on it... again, i'm sorry bout what i said earlier,hope i din offend anyone..
Posted Image
 
NorthernLight[Zzz]
Member Avatar


I don't think there's only My generation in the mv, i feel like TOKYO is also in there (train part) well.. since the director have apologized, i have no comment
Posted Image
Posted Image<------ Play-Asia.com - Your One-Stop-Shop for Asian Entertainment
 
gotchi
Member Avatar
☆ カナダの人 ☆

oh wow...interesting..i'm glad that the director acknowledged and apologized this...

haven't heard of this singer before but this song sounds nice...

yea i guess its hard to keep track of whats been done out there all the time...even though she's signed under Sony BMG while YUI is under Sony Music Japan....it's a huge and hectic world out there and ii mean people do make mistakes! but as long as they know what they've done and apologize it's all good.
Posted Image

As if losing my way, get away get away ♪♫

fun YUI Sound Buttons created by Kikino!

gotchi's report of YUI's 3rd~oui I LOVED YESTERDAY Concert in Nagano!
gotchi's report of YUI's Hong Kong HOTEL HOLIDAYS IN THE SUN Concert!
 
mono
Member Avatar
We are YUIing!!

j.k
Aug 4 2007, 07:15 AM
right...sorry bout what i said about her earlier :swt ...it's just that i dun like it when somebody tries to copy YUI. well,since everyone says it's ok,guess there's no point to dwell on it... again, i'm sorry bout what i said earlier,hope i din offend anyone..

I wasn't offened by you
and I'm not blaming on you

I just don't want any of us blaming blindly on wrong people which I have seen such thing happen in other YUI fansites
Acting like that would do nothing good but make others think YUI's fans are immature and this may affect YUI's image

Hope you can understand me :)
Posted ImagePosted ImageYUI-net
Posted Image
 
locast
Member Avatar
A Big Yui Lover

did i read wrongly or is that did that song recived 4 awards in something nomination awards

she copied and got rewards
wow

didnt notice this thing b4 it happened since july?
千羽 Chiba (thousand feathers) 大輝 Taiki (large radiance)

Posted Image Posted Image
 
Dnee Chan
Member Avatar
Can't Buy Me Love

locast
Aug 4 2007, 11:40 AM
did i read wrongly or is that did that song recived 4 awards in something nomination awards

she copied and got rewards
wow

didnt notice this thing b4 it happened since july?

Hm... that MV wins 4 Awards??? :blink: What the.... but I think the director must at least review it before it's come out :unsure:
Posted Image
 
j.k
Member Avatar
Resurrected

mono
Aug 4 2007, 06:08 PM
j.k
Aug 4 2007, 07:15 AM
right...sorry bout what i said about her earlier :swt ...it's just that i dun like it when somebody tries to copy YUI. well,since everyone says it's ok,guess there's no point to dwell on it... again, i'm sorry bout what i said earlier,hope i din offend anyone..

I wasn't offened by you
and I'm not blaming on you

I just don't want any of us blaming blindly on wrong people which I have seen such thing happen in other YUI fansites
Acting like that would do nothing good but make others think YUI's fans are immature and this may affect YUI's image

Hope you can understand me :)

i'm glad you're not angry :lol: ... guess i was acting too rashly earlier...
Posted Image
 
Deleted User
Deleted User

i just watched it..mmnn...dont know what to say,,
but yui's style is simply the best...
 
NorthernLight[Zzz]
Member Avatar


she got reward? ok i keep my word, the director's bad, copying YUI's pv is unforgiveable
Posted Image
Posted Image<------ Play-Asia.com - Your One-Stop-Shop for Asian Entertainment
 
locast
Member Avatar
A Big Yui Lover

yes from the youtube webby there

its says
Quote:
 
This is only propaganda music video with no commercial purpose

Zhang before "like" MV on the Internet by netizens criticized correction involving plagiarism. all respect from Zhang individuals and teacher Lee because all original, informed the matter deeply ashamed and sad. has also issued a statement this netizen Zhang my knowledge, as well as the acts of plagiarism denounced Netizen's correction will be conveyed to Sony BMG. Sony BMG than on the cross Netizen provided information, that some fragments are too exact duplication them. Sony BMG failure to fulfill its supervision MV directors and creative responsibilities, deeply sorry, and strict demands more staff to avoid the occurrence of similar situations, also hope that all employees in the industry can uphold respect for the conscience of originality, creativity resist any plagiarism, respect for others, creativity, more respect for their own actions, so that Taiwan's music industry not to untold misery. Bertelsmann hereby declare Sony Music Entertainment Corp. July 24, 2007

Desert Xuan 2007 New Album coming soon...

Long a favorite amongst live music aficionados, female Taiwanese singer-songwriter Deserts Chang made the leap from the pub circuit to a major record label last year with her debut album My Life Will... The album went on to garner four nominations at the 2007 Golden Melody Awards including Best Song of the Year and Best Mandarin Album, bringing the talented artist into mainstream attention. Though more eyes and ears are on her now for her second album, this indie darling stays true to her musical roots with an earthy selection of poetic, guitar-driven numbers. Her new album comes with 12 tracks, including first plug "Like".

Product Information

Product Title : Oh, dear. dear. I haven't.
Singer Name(s) : Deserts Chang
Release Date : July 20, 2007
Publisher : SonyBMG Music Entertainment(TW) (more) (less)


wat does it means by garner
is it that it was jus chosen as one of the posibilities?
or did the album really won it
千羽 Chiba (thousand feathers) 大輝 Taiki (large radiance)

Posted Image Posted Image
 
sonic87
I LOVE YUI!!!

Dnee Chan
Aug 4 2007, 07:54 PM
locast
Aug 4 2007, 11:40 AM
did i read wrongly or is that did that song recived 4 awards in something nomination awards

she copied and got rewards
wow

didnt notice this thing b4 it happened since july?

Hm... that MV wins 4 Awards??? :blink: What the.... but I think the director must at least review it before it's come out :unsure:

Nah... This MV did not and will not win anything...

The 4 nominations were for her previous which is her debut album "My Life will..."


Her songs are actually not bad... Just that... YUI is the BEST!!!
 
gnaxiw
Member Avatar
Yui's no. 1!!

The song actually sounds quite pleasant..
Posted Image
 
>ch|yo<
Member Avatar
yui daisuki~

:o the beginning...and the end...i still like YUI's version better...
Posted Image
credits : siggy-baboshi @ soshified.com
 
Yukia
Member Avatar


The beginning was exactly the same... :swt
 
Deleted User
Deleted User

Zhang Xuan is a taiwanese singer. Her first album My Life Will... was really good! One of the songs on the album was what got me into chinese pop.

Both her and YUI have similar styles (singer-guitarist type) and both have released 2 albums. However, her music is more laidback. And whereas YUI changed style on Can't Buy My Love, Zhang Xuan's 2nd album was almost similar to her first. And both of them have similar backgrounds. YUI started out performing on the streets while Zhang Xuan started out performing at live pubs/bars all over Taiwan.

Anyway I enjoy both of them. You guys should check her music out if you have the chance.
 
benzwong
Member Avatar
Daijoubu!

Has to be a copy! How can the setting and props be exactly the same! Even the camera angle is similar, she could have walked towards the right side lol.

Still, blame the director, don't blame the singer please.

This song called "Bao Bei" (Baby) in her first album is so nice. At least give her some credit :lol:
Posted Image
Is there a male version of this shirt? So nice!
 
gotchi
Member Avatar
☆ カナダの人 ☆

well when it comes to film...its hard to sometimes create/avoid things that are kinda "cliche"...i mean the whole guitar pick and handing it off thing feels a bit cliche to me especially when considering how both artists have somewhat similar styles being singer/songwriters who plays guitars......so i wouldnt be surprised someone else would think of it...it's just too bad no staff caught the similarities before releasing it...

i'm willing to give a listen to Zhang Xuan...tiamat would u mind uploading her albums somewhere?
Posted Image

As if losing my way, get away get away ♪♫

fun YUI Sound Buttons created by Kikino!

gotchi's report of YUI's 3rd~oui I LOVED YESTERDAY Concert in Nagano!
gotchi's report of YUI's Hong Kong HOTEL HOLIDAYS IN THE SUN Concert!
 
eonridr
Member Avatar
Yui's de WaY tO Go!!!~

we know alot of parts is so ripped off i cant bare to watch.. but if u just listen the music quite okay.. and yea the awards r her previous achievement.. nothing to do with this mv.

the singer is innocent.. the director is gulity. i just feel sad that the singer Zhang Xuan's name could be negatively affected because of this. but i guess it can't be helped in this industry.

n on another note.. Yui is good :P
Posted Image
Yui is cute! XD
No matter Yui is Rock or shy I'll always support the Yui!
 
Deleted User
Deleted User

Yes that's the song Baobei that got me into cpop. There are 2 versions. In the night and In the Day.

Here's her second album. You must register on the site to download the torrent though.

http://mullemeck.serveftp.org/jps_beta/for...ghlight=deserts

I'll upload her 1st one on yousendit when I wake up.
 
Merry.Go.Round
Member Avatar


I've got to say the beginning of the MV is exactly the same..
The middle and the end doesn't seem to be the same..
Posted Image
-Anata wa zurui hito-
 
NorthernLight[Zzz]
Member Avatar


the middle looks like tokyo to me when she's on the train
Posted Image
Posted Image<------ Play-Asia.com - Your One-Stop-Shop for Asian Entertainment
 
*simply_kawaii*
Member Avatar
Call me *sky* for short..^^

NorthernLight[Zzz
 
,Aug 7 2007, 11:57 AM] the middle looks like tokyo to me when she's on the train

i observed that too.. ;)
i want to ask something, does she play guitar?
sig made by me XD
Posted Image

 
>ch|yo<
Member Avatar
yui daisuki~

angela100290
Aug 7 2007, 08:15 PM
i observed that too.. ;)
i want to ask something, does she play guitar?

yes she does indeed :)
like YUI she is a singer-songwriter too...and she is considered to be one of the leading alternative musicians in the Chinese music industry.

Posted Image
credits : siggy-baboshi @ soshified.com
 
gotchi
Member Avatar
☆ カナダの人 ☆

Tiamat
Aug 7 2007, 02:49 AM
Yes that's the song Baobei that got me into cpop. There are 2 versions. In the night and In the Day.

Here's her second album. You must register on the site to download the torrent though.

http://mullemeck.serveftp.org/jps_beta/for...ghlight=deserts

I'll upload her 1st one on yousendit when I wake up.

thanks Tiamat! i'll check it out...
Posted Image

As if losing my way, get away get away ♪♫

fun YUI Sound Buttons created by Kikino!

gotchi's report of YUI's 3rd~oui I LOVED YESTERDAY Concert in Nagano!
gotchi's report of YUI's Hong Kong HOTEL HOLIDAYS IN THE SUN Concert!
 
bo_thug
Member Avatar
*blink!*

oh, snap. it's a darn rip-off! i'm guessing the director is running outta ideas? haha. jokes on both the director and the singer [no offense, but yeah]. :damnpc
YUI's version of My Generation and TOKYO is way, WAY BETTER! sorry director, dude. the song's kinda lame too [to me that is..haha]. sorry to ya too, dear singer. YUI's much cute looking and her music is way cooler. :P :P
Facebook / Twitter / deviantArt / Blogger / Tumblr / NOKSS#0
 
zenaku
Member Avatar


guess the director is a YUI fan, quite like the song itself, too bad they found the wrong director to do the pv.
http://www.myspace.com/halcyonhk
http://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Halcyon/188835858512?ref=ts
 
bo_thug
Member Avatar
*blink!*

darn right, zenaku. WRONG CHOICE of director. ;p
Facebook / Twitter / deviantArt / Blogger / Tumblr / NOKSS#0
 
Dlyan
Member Avatar


unbelievable ! :damnpc

but the original will be always better :rolleyes:
Posted Image
 
fat
Member Avatar
>.<~Depapepe!~Yui~>.<

Aaaa!~ Man, I'm chinese-filipino, and I like chinese music but I have to say, "aww, why?!!! same!?"

Director must be a YUI addict.
>.<
Maybe he's like dreaming of YUI and her MV while directing and stuff like that.
Dreaming like US.. :3
Hahaha oh well WE STILL LOVE YUI~
Guh huh huh huh >.<
 
houseboyz
Member Avatar


Hmm can't belive people do this maybe they ran out of idea thats all bah
Posted Image
 
ZetaBoards - Free Forum Hosting
Create your own social network with a free forum.
Learn More · Sign-up for Free
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · General News · Next Topic »
Add Reply